Entries Tagged as ''

Third Person Point of View

I recently completed Three Cups of Tea: One Man’s Mission to Promote Peace . . . One School at a Time by Greg Mortensen and David Oliver Relin.  The book describes Mortensen’s gifts of time, energy, and devotion when building schools in the remote regions of Northern Pakistan.  Interestingly, Mortensen did not start out with the intention to promote peace, but the notion evolved as he came to know and understand the people of Pakistan and witness his own country’s overt errors resulting from a lack of understanding.

Three Cups of TeaWhat really intrigued me, however, is the co-author David Oliver Relin. Relin’s picture appears in the book and one assumes he is the narrator of the story since Mortensen is spoken of in third person. I think it is interesting that no mention is made of when Relin enters the scene and actually begins to witness the things that are written. Certainly much of the early story is written as it was told to him. Then at some point he met Mortensen and was invited to collaborate on the book or maybe he offered to collaborate. I wonder about the decision to make him the narrator of the story rather than write the narrative in first person since both men’s names are listed as author. It’s a journalistic approach for sure and perhaps a good one, but I kept waiting for Relin to arrive in the story so apparent were his sensibilities in the tale.

As I prepare to write a non-fiction book, one in which I will relate the stories of 10 women inventors, I’m very conscious of point of view. I generally find first person point of view more compelling, but that wasn’t so with Three Cups of Tea.

So the question is: How did Relin accomplish a profound level of intimacy and a compelling degree of potency when employing a third person perspective? Was it the story itself? Or was it protagonist Mortensen’s strength of character? I’m sure it was both of these. But I also think it was more . . . something in the way Relin manages the material. A closer look is in order.

What does it take to make compelling storytelling from third person point of view?

The Power of Point of View

I’m getting tired of receiving political email, usually messages that have been forwarded hundreds of times. I’m sick of reading blog posts that slander or at least underline the foibles of McCain and Palin. But yesterday I got an email message–it was another forward– that brought me up short and made me think about perspective and point of view.

Early on as writers, we learn to consider the importance and relevance of point of view in writing. Here are segments of the email message that made me shiver, that frightened me and forced me to recognize how deeply entrenched our country is in a racist point of view.

What if things were switched around? Consider the following:

What if the Obamas had paraded five children across the stage, including a three month old infant and an unwed, pregnant teenage daughter?

What if John McCain was a former president of the Harvard Law Review?

What if McCain had only married once and Obama was a divorcee?

What if Obama had met his second wife in a bar and had a long affair while he was still married?

What if Cindy McCain had graduated from Harvard?

What if Obama had been a member of the Keating Five? (The Keating Five were five United States Senators accused of corruption in 1989, igniting a major political scandal as part of the larger Savings and Loan crisis of the late 1980s and early 1990s.)

obama-mccain_l.jpgWhy aren’t people talking about John Sydney McCain if they are saying Barack Hussein Obama?

What if Obama was the one who had military experience that included discipline problems and a record of crashing three planes?

This is what racism does. It covers up, rationalizes, and minimizes the positive qualities in one candidate and emphasizes negative qualities in another when there is a color difference.

Education isn’t everything, but I think it should be a part of one’s perspective when evaluating candidates for the most important position in the country. Consider the disparate educational backgrounds of the Presidential and Vice Presidential candidates:

Barack Obama:
Columbia University - B.A. Political Science with a Specialization in International Relations.
Harvard - Juris Doctor (J.D.) Magna Cum Laude

Joseph Biden:
University of Delaware - B.A. in History and B.A. in Political Science.
Syracuse University College of Law - Juris Doctor (J.D.)

John McCain:
United States Naval Academy - Class rank: 894 of 899

Sarah Palin:
Hawaii Pacific University - 1 semester
North Idaho College - 2 semesters - general study
University of Idaho - 3 semesters - B.A. in Journalism

There is no minimizing the power of point of view when one considers how much harder a bi-racial man has to work to reach the same heights as a white man or a white woman.

Kate Evans on Process

Author Kate Evans writes in not one but several genres: fiction, poetry (Like All We Love), non-fiction (Negotiating the Self), and blogging. In each case, she demonstrates clear competence managing the distinctive features particular to the genre. Kate is one smart lady.

For the May QueenIn the following interview, she responds to questions I asked about her process when writing her newly published novel For the May Queen. I was interested in how Kate’s “editeyes” worked as she approached the task of writing fiction.

ME: The setting of For the May Queen is dorm-life culture in the early 1980s, focusing on drinking, drugs, and sex prevalent in such a context. As a 60-year-old woman who came of age in the late 1960s, I admit to feeling a sense of disturbing recognition as well as powerless disappointment as I read, particularly during the first 2/3rds of the story. You manage to present this as a valid context for a rite of passage without minimizing it as a societal problem. Can you speak to how you arrived at telling a story that takes place in this particular context?

KATE: I lived in the dorms in the early 1980s.  I was always interested in writing about that experience.  I even tried to write about it as memoir, but that didn’t work for me. I worked on a lot of other things for years–poems, stories–when one day Norma’s voice came to me.  Then the dorms emerged as the setting.  It wasn’t really a conscious choice, but clearly that setting had been brewing in my mind for quite some time. 

The dorms are a good setting, I think, because there are many juicy built-in conflicts.  I chose the early 1980s because I didn’t want to deal with the internet and cell phones!  Well, that’s part of it.  The other part is, retro and nostalgia are fun.

ME: It is often said that a fiction writer’s first novel is to a great extent autobiographical. I’m interested in how this was so for you, particularly in terms of the characters in the story. Assuming there were prototypes in your experience for these characters, how and when did they become their own entities, more fictional and less the individuals from whom they originated?

KATE: I like that the semi-autobiographical novel is and is not the writer.  I think this genre or sub-genre allows us to play around with the slipperiness of the self.  I’m both Norma and not-Norma.  Norma’s both Kate and not-Kate.  It’s fun to play around like that.  As Jeanette Winterson says, reading yourself as fiction is liberating.

Of course memoirists do this too, to an extent–it’s just that the readers are more likely to see memoir as you, whereas readers have to grapple with fiction as being both you and not you.  I think it’s fun and exciting because I like identity to be in motion.

The characters became more fictional and then paradoxically more real–more truly themselves–the more I wrote them.  They became three-dimensional as they grappled with all the roadblocks I placed in their way, as they made choices and interacted and, ideally, grew.

ME: I particularly enjoyed the symbolism in the character’s names and how their names fleshed out the central theme about identity. For instance, Norma sits at the center of the story, thereby establishing the “norm” which is not exactly normal, and who is also called Norma Jean by Chuck thereby alluding to the subtext of the Marilyn Monroe persona. Chuck, who is really Paul, is renamed by Norma, consistent with his dual identity and her failure to see the real him.  Can you talk about the naming of characters and the degree to which your choices were consciously symbolic?

This is cool! Thanks for the great insights.  I didn’t make conscious choices about the names, but clearly my unconcious was busy at work.  It takes a reader like you to enter the story and help me see the method to the madness of my unconcious. 

When Norma walked into Paul’s dorm room, I didn’t know they were going to play around with each other’s names.  Paul’s calling Norma “Norma Jean” is led to his becoming a film buff–which evolved into being an essential aspect of his character.  Norma’s renaming Paul is certainly a way for her to claim him and to not-see him, but I didn’t have this in mind as I wrote it.  The playful banter was just part of their rapport.

ME: There are other symbols in the story: bridges, mirrors, and games, along with cultural icons like James Bond and Marilyn Monroe. The story explores themes like nonconformity, altered states, friendship, marriage, and even education and the relative value of an instructor’s choices for her students. How much of this arose organically in the story? Did you ever discover something inherent in the tale that you developed in the revision process?

KATE: All of it arose organically.  When a friend of mine read the manuscript, she noticed a bunch of references to fairy tales, like “Billy Goats Gruff ” and “Goldilocks.”  I didn’t know that was all in there.  That’s what’s so wonderful about writing.  It takes the readers to enrich, to complete, the experience.

I do think I amped up some of these patterns and recurrences in my revision, but not with an eye to theme.  It was more with an eye to repetition as a satisfying way to weave patterns into, or out of, chaos.

ME: Finally, you’ve mentioned that your editor sent you back to the drawing board to write a denouement—the second to the last chapter. Would you talk about your process in writing this chapter?

This was actually my agent who did this.  At any rate, he said he wanted to know the fall-out of Norma’s discoveries that are essentially the novel’s climax.  I realized he was right, that we never know what Norma does to grapple with what she suddenly sees.  Sorry for being so vague, but I don’t want to give away what Norma discovers for those who haven’t read the novel.  

At any rate, Norma discovers something big.  But my agent was right, the book couldn’t just end there.  We had to know how she grappled with what she discovered.  After I resisted for a while, it turned out to be really fun to watch her deal with this alone.  She turns to a book, in fact, for advice.  It’s the longest section in the novel that she’s alone, reading and thinking.  She gets more quiet and still than at any other part of the novel.  I saw her growing up just a little bit, right there.  It was very cool, and it provided a bridge to the last chapter.

Thanks Kate. I wonder if my readers have questions for you.

1 Way to Realize Life

On my last day in Ashland, I walked with two other women, Kim and Haley, to buy squash soup at Pangea restaurant. All along the way, we read freestyle chalked graffiti on the sidewalks–the late night mischief of our fellow travelers to theater-land. We laughed at the imagination apropos in each line we encountered.

As we waited for our soup, we each spoke about one thing we would take with us from the trip. Haley described being particularly moved by a line from “Our Town” about the swiftness of 1000 days passing.  The gist of the quote was about “realizing life while you live it.” She was going to write in her journal every day for a 1000 days, beginning right then. Kim and I decided to join her in this plan, and we made a pact that we would each write daily.

I’ve written in my journal for 7 days straight. Right from the start, I struggled with whether to write about daily happenings or “practice” creative writing. I’ve written in a journal intermittently for years. For instance, I generally write when I’m on a trip like the one to Ashland, noting emotions, sights, impulses, and plans that arise from being in a new and different place. Whenever I teach writing classes, I write with my students to the prompts I give them. Sometimes, I get on a roll at home and write for several days or weeks using pictures or poems or nature as prompts, but then for reasons unknown I stop this daily journaling. So the commitment to write for 1000 days is challenging, particularly in terms of what to write.

Writing Down the bonesThis morning, I wrote several pages about what I should be writing and why I was writing, and then I decided to get one of my favorite books off the shelf– Natalie Goldberg’s Writing Down the Bones– to point me in a more fruitful direction.  I opened the book and read several pages, and when I came to a segment called “Nervously Sipping Wine” on page 66, I knew I’d found the guidance I was looking for.

Here’s the suggestion that did it for me.  Goldberg recommended for a starting line to “take the first half of your sentence from a newspaper article and finish the sentence with an ingredient listed in a cookbook.” I modified these instructions because I didn’t feel like getting up to retrieve her ingredients. Instead, I copied a line from the AARP Bulletin that was sitting on the end table by my chair and finished it with a phrase from the Columbia Nursery Newsletter also sitting nearby.

Woah!!! From that first line emerged two pages of the best stuff I’ve written in a LONG time.

Try it! It’s a powerful journal exercise not unlike mischievously composing sidewalk graffiti in chalk.  And while you’re at it, join my friends and me in writing in your journal for 1000 days. Maybe we can all do a better job of realizing life while we live it.

If you do decided to commit, how about making the commitment public by dropping a statement to that effect in the comment section here.

ph

Embody the Image

I first learned about making the abstract physical during a seminar offered by Paul Lisicky, one of my instructors at Antioch University.  We took the study of “show don’t tell” deeper, looking at how writers make the body–its sensations and movement– integral to an image. My understanding of “embodiment” and writing deepened when I read Gayle Brandeis‘ book Fruitflesh.

During a recent trip to the Oregon Shakespeare Festival, I revisited the power of physicality in writing while taking part in an actor’s workshop. Our workshop focused on how an audience views a play through a cultural lens. We did a number of exercises to get in touch with cultural and societal concepts, particularly those in the last 60 years, and then we looked closely at language in the plays we would be seeing, teasing out specific images and working with them.

Most importantly, we got actively involved with the imagery. For instance, in one activity we were broken into groups to study a small passage from “Midsummer’s Night Dream.” Our instructions were to chose a line of text and create a tableau that expressed that text in terms of the culture and thinking of the 1950s. What was most interesting was the process of finding a way to express the words visually so that our audience (the rest of the class) would get it. Here is my group’s line of text and a picture of our tableau:

Egeus speaking to the Duke after Hermia, his daughter, has told him she wishes to marry Lysander rather than Demetrius, his choice for her:

Egeus:  “As she is mine, I may dispose of her.”

Hermia-tableau

We made the image graphic by having one of the men shove a woman’s head into a trash can while the other women cowered submissively nearby, with one exception.  In the background, this woman was “just” stepping up onto a chair, beginning to rise above such patriarchal behavior, to signify the rumbling of change in the 1950s.

I walked away from this workshop considering how effective ACTING is in feeling the meaning behind an image. We actually took the line of text into our bodies as we worked with it.

Now my question is how can I bring this “knowing” into my writing? How do I get more engaged physically as I write? I have a few ideas but wonder if you, dear readers, have your thoughts about embodiment and writing?

Artist Dates

Recently, I mentioned Julia Cameron’s idea about Artist Dates, and it seems the mere mention of this idea manifested one big fat date for me. According to Cameorn’s description, the Artist’s Date is a block of time especially set aside for nurturing your creative consciousness–an excursion, a play date that you take all by yourself–quality time in which you open yourself to insight, inspiration and guidance for your art form.

My block of time was 5 days long. The excursion was to the Oregon Shakespeare Festival in Ashland. The playdate involved 15 students from Columbia College and their instructor who invited me on the spur of the moment to fill a vacant seat on the trip. Let me add that the students with the exception of one were all under 30. Everyone was energetic, intelligent, imaginative, spontaneous, crazy to play, talented in a multiplicity of ways, and above all generous and joy-filled.

shakespeare.jpgFor 5 days, I cavorted with this group, sleeping little, playing lots, seeing fabulous plays and spending time in workshops with bright, incredible members of the OSF theater company. I’m saturated and sated with   “insight, inspiration and guidance” and plan to describe some of the relevant experience here over the next few days.

This was my third trip to Ashland and last year, I wrote about the trip on my other blog Twilightme in a post called Shakespeare TaDum. Take a look at that post for the kind of material such a trip offers in the way of an Artist’s Date.

In writing about this year’s trip, I’m going to break apart the experience, writing here about the parts that I think will serve as fodder for other writers while I report more personal insights on Twilightme.

Today, I will simply say that whether you take 5 minutes, 5 hours, or 5 days, I recommend consistently making room in your life for such dates. They stretch your perspective beyond the perimeter of your notebook or computer screen, offering incomparable color, texture, and novelty.

Expand our possibilities for such experiences by dropping a note in the comments about your most recent Artist’s Date.

Blog Tour

 A year or so ago, when I was starting to think about how to promote my book once it was published, I stumbled upon the concept of blog tours. Rather than take one’s book on the road to various venues, the idea is to get it reviewed and or get yourself interviewed on a bunch of blogs. It saves lots of money and works well with the idea of viral promotion, that is passing the word about your book from friend to friend. This method of promotion is supposed to be highly successful.

To that end, I started asking friends if they would be willing to read my book, Between Two Women, and do a post about it or me. Several noteworthy friends responded with a YES! Links to their posts follow.

But first, I’d like to say that being interviewed is a very powerful self-reflective exercise. Each of these writers/bloggers asked different kinds of questions. I think the 3 interviews probe into unique aspects of my process and intention. As such, they opened my Editeyes, demanding that I look at the work in new ways. I hope you will visit these blogs and then come back and comment here. The circular dialogue will certainly benefit all of us.

KeitiKeiti Pierce who is currently a student of the Gothic novel at Stirling University in Scotland did a four part interview on Misplaced Misfit.

Gayle BrandeisGayle Brandeis who wrote Self Storage interviewed me on her blog Fruitflesh.

Kate EvansKate Evan, interviewed me on Being and Writing. Her book For the May Queen was just published, and I will be interviewing Kate here next week about the book and her approach to writing.

Finally, I’m excited to announce that I’ll be interviewed on Women-Stirred Radio on Thursday Oct. 9 at 4pm EST. You can stream it live at www.wgdr.org by clicking on the “Listen Live” link. If you are in California, you need to check in at 1pm.

Thanks to each of these women writers for spreading a net of support for this writer in the sometimes overwhelming task of promoting a book.

Showing up

 Eighty percent of success is showing up.
–Woody Allen

I often feel like I don’t have the time I want or need to focus on my writing. That’s why it works for me to stay connected with other writers who never cease to provide pointed reminders about how I can put writing first in my life.

This week’s reminder came from Rebecca Lawton in the October issue of her newsletter Write Free. I met Lawton four years ago at a weekend writing retreat up in Philo.

Rebecca LawtonLawton suggests making a pact with yourself to show up at your desk at least three days a week, ten minutes a day. Trick yourself into starting in on your creative project du jour by saying, “It’s just ten minutes. When I’m done, I can head off to other tasks.”

I immediately took on this assignment and had marvelous results. I’d been putting off a freelance project for days, telling myself I didn’t have a enough time to give to it fully. But Saturday, I told myself to give it just 10 minutes. Amazingly that was enough. I worked longer than 10 minutes because once I got started I didn’t want to stop AND when I had to stop to deal with some necessary chores, I continued to think about the project and returned to finish it later in the day because I had indirectly been engaged with it all day.

Lawton also connected the idea of showing up to the November election. Though I hesitate to regard myself as political, I long ago came to understand what the second wave feminists promoted, that is “the personal is political.” As Carol Hanisch said in an essay dated March 1969: “One of the first things we learn in the [encounter] groups is that personal problems are political problems.” So allow me, like Lawton, to move the idea of showing up in a political direction. fighton-cover-72.jpeg

Lawton wrote: “Showing up also counts when it comes to our democratic process–something much in the minds of American voters today.” One of my favorite bloggers, Tuckova, posted this great video about showing up: Five Friends

Give yourself 5 minutes to watch the video and then spend 10 minutes on a writing project.That’s a total of 15 minutes. Surely you have that to spare.

I’d be delighted if you’d write a few sentences in the comment section about how you spent 10 minutes writing.

2 Ways to Work as an Artist

I read the Artist’s Way by Julia Cameron close to twenty years ago. While some of her ideas were a little too gooey for me, I did come away with two practices that I regularly use to stimulate my writing.

One is morning pages. While I don’t write in my journal every morning, I do write EVERY day . . . Here are some things I count as creative writing:

  • freewriting with my students
  • writing a blog entry
  • writing an email message that describes
  • responding to a blog with a comment the extends the conversation
  • writing a review on GoodReads
  • creating a greeting card (birthday, anniversary, congratulations)
  • business correspondence that uses colorful examples to make my point
  • writing love notes to my sweetie that go in her lunch box

The second thing I learned from Cameron is making artist dates, i.e. creating opportunities to nurture my creative consciousness. Since I’m fascinated by imagery, I often look toward the visual artists to feed this element of my creativity. Visual artists have taught me much about:

  • focal point
  • juxtaposition
  • color
  • perspective
  • depth

Love My LifeFilms are particularly good at serving up wonderful studies in visual imagery. I recently watched a Japanese film that was a marvelous eye feast in which the imagery fed the message: Love My Life.  (It got a lousy review on Rotten Tomatoes, but I thought the filming was amazing and happened to like the story very much.)

And here is an amazing visual collage on YouTube that made me want to take a videography class. I watched this clip 5 times ever marveling at the way these images work together and with the music.

These are two ways I work to stimulate my writing life. What do you do to keep your art alive?


View My Stats